There is a good article by Christine Rosen that asks, Women Dominate America’s Pews, Is that a Problem? The answer I think, is "yes." When a whole gender is dropping off from church attendance in droves, we have a large problem. If this was reversed, and women were not attending church, certain groups would be up in arms, holding boycotts, and developing some "theology" to correct it. Where are the "masculinist theologians"? When are classes on the masculine interpretation of Scripture going to be offered? When is the offensive quote of Jesus about gathering Jerusalem like a hen going to be exised from the Bible so men no longer get offended by the feminine imagery? Ok, I got a little started here…
My favorite observation of the whole piece:
Interestingly, Mr. Murrow notes that, among the major Christian denominations,
it is the mainline churches that suffer the largest gender gaps in church
attendance. These churches, still pilloried by feminists for their patriarchal
pretensions, have in fact become spiritual sorority houses. It is the more
conservative denominations, such as the Southern Baptists, that have the most
even ratios.
[note: I think the same is true of race and class. Even though many mainlines like the Episcopal church talk about diversity, most are still educated, upper-class, white folks. If you want to see real diversity, even though they don’t always talk about it, go to a Pentecostal or Catholic Church.]
So…Where are all the men? According to the article, in churches like the Catholic Church that have dimensions emphasizing spiritual rigor and competition. Where are men not? In lovey-dovey, feel-good, bland churches, both liberal and conservative. I don’t have all the answers, but I think we have a problem here. This is probably the fifth article I have read on this topic since I have started this blog, so even without the information presented in this article, we seem to have a real problem.
Hat tip: Canon Kendall Harmon