Reactions to My Becoming Catholic
Saturday, January 29th, 2005
Charles has blogged about reactions to his becoming Catholic. I thought it would be neat to write an entry about reactions to my conversion.
Despite living in an area that can be hostile to Catholics, the responses to my conversion have been largely positive. My family is supportive of course, although I don’t think they fully understand why anybody my age would abandon individualistic evangelical theology and praxis for a more structured, traditional way of doing things. Nonetheless, they have been supportive and open.
My friends’ reactions have been positive as well. My secular friends are a bit mystified, but they have always been mystified as to the place religion plays in my life. My Christian friends’ reactions have been positive and understanding. Steve (who attends a pentecostal church) was kind of surprised, but was encouraging, even visiting Mass with us one Sunday. One of the main reasons is that of all the Christians he has encountered, my brother and I have been probably the least judgmental. His church is pretty legalistic about drinking, and he quite rightly sees nothing wrong in having a beer now and then. He has asked us about a few doctrinal issues, and we have had some good discussions about both of our churches. Usually the response from Christian friends is simply anticlimactic; they are glad we are happy, and have no objections or concerns, and speak positively about Catholics they have known or worked with.
One friend and co-worker was really shocked. He has been a friend of the family for years and got red in the face with shock and laughed when he found out my brother and I converted. He was really surprised, since in this area, kids of evangelicals don’t usually become Catholic. To be honest, around here they usually become practical agnostics, but that is another post entirely. But his reaction was surprise, not judgment. Another co-worker also found out, and found it fascinating, and talked about how we worship the same Lord, etc. Later she told me how her Methodist church blessed animals one Sunday. I thought that was cool.
My Episcopal friends were not surprised, because they have witnessed my displeasure with the Anglican church for some time, and they have been very encouraging. I still encourage them in their ministries as well, and we have remained good friends.
Honestly, there have been no negative responses yet. Some people just don’t know though. I do not hide my being Catholic, nor do I announce it to everyone inappropriately. I didn’t announce my Episcopalianism or Evangelicalism to the world when I was involved in those groups either. As more people find out, I could encounter some negative reactions, but honestly, with my background and spiritual journey, I am well-equipped to deal with it all.
Image from: http://www.stmarys-slough.org.uk/1/conf.htm





